A candlelit table for two beside a restaurant window overlooking softly lit brick buildings at December dusk.

The Nutcracker Comes to Penn Avenue Three Ways, Under Billy Strayhorn's Name

On Saturday, December 12, Confluence Ballet stages its Jazz Nutcracker at Kelly Strayhorn Theater, 5941 Penn Ave. The score is the Duke Ellington and Billy Strayhorn jazz adaptation. The building took Strayhorn's name, along with Gene Kelly's, in 2000, to honor two Pittsburgh natives. That's an unusual piece of local continuity. It also kicks off a six-day run with three different Nutcrackers on the same stage, and the night before, East Liberty Presbyterian Church holds its own holiday concert at 116 South Highland Avenue.

East Liberty's biggest holiday performances fall within a single week on the Penn and Highland core. The three Nutcrackers are different enough that picking one says a lot about the evening you want.

A 1914 Movie House With a Jazz Composer's Name

The building is older than its name. According to Kelly Strayhorn Theater's history page, it opened in 1914 as the Regent Theatre, a 1,100-seat photoplay house designed by Harry S. Bair. It was renamed in 2000 for Kelly and Strayhorn.

That history explains why the Jazz Nutcracker fits here better than most touring holiday shows would. Confluence Ballet's version keeps Clara's story and the familiar melodies, but the music runs through Strayhorn's arrangement. On stage, the company brings in the Pittsburgh Pride Choir, members of the queer line dancing club 412 Step, circus performers and vogue dancers. It's a Nutcracker built from Pittsburgh's own performers, played in a Pittsburgh composer's theater.

The Week, Night by Night

Here's how the dates fall, from the church sanctuary on Friday through the last Nutcracker the following Thursday.

Date Event Venue Time Tickets
Fri., Dec. 11 Christmas in East Liberty ELPC Sanctuary, 116 S. Highland Ave. 7:30–9 p.m. Series concerts free unless noted
Sat., Dec. 12 Confluence Ballet, Jazz Nutcracker Kelly Strayhorn Theater, 5941 Penn Ave. 7 p.m. $35; $25 students, seniors 65+, kids under 12
Sun., Dec. 13 Confluence Ballet, Jazz Nutcracker Kelly Strayhorn Theater 2 p.m. Same as Saturday; under 3 free with an adult ticket
Wed., Dec. 16 Art in Motion, Winter Fair & Pittsburgh Community Nutcracker Kelly Strayhorn Theater 5–8:30 p.m. Pay what moves you, $10–$20
Thu., Dec. 17 Grand Kyiv Ballet, Nutcracker: Symphony of Lights Kelly Strayhorn Theater 7 p.m. $39–$59

East Liberty Presbyterian Church calls Christmas in East Liberty "An East Liberty Holiday Tradition." It's part of the church's Cathedral Concerts series, and the series page lists its concerts as free unless otherwise noted. Friday's concert gets the week started, and the theater carries the rest.

Three Nutcrackers, Three Different Nights Out

Every show on the theater's run is "The Nutcracker," but they don't offer the same evening. Here's how to tell them apart.

For the music: the Jazz Nutcracker, Dec. 12 and 13. If the Ellington and Strayhorn score is the reason you're going, this is your show. Two performances give you a choice between a Saturday evening and a Sunday matinee. At $25, the student, senior and under-12 price is low enough that a family outing doesn't have to be a splurge.

For participation and shopping: the Winter Fair & Pittsburgh Community Nutcracker, Dec. 16. Art in Motion Pittsburgh's annual evening is half performance, half fair. Students and instructors perform and give demonstrations, and the excerpts from The Pittsburgh Community Nutcracker feature children, adults and community members dancing together. Local vendors sell handmade goods and gifts, kids and adults can make a decoration to take home at the holiday craft tables, and vendors donate the door prizes. It runs 5 to 8:30 p.m. on a Wednesday, and tickets are pay what moves you, $10 to $20. That makes it the easiest of the three to fit into a school night.

For spectacle: Nutcracker: Symphony of Lights, Dec. 17. Grand Kyiv Ballet's production is built around glowing costumes and lighting effects. At $39 to $59, it's the priciest seat of the week and the closest to a traditional touring ballet. It's a single Thursday performance, so there's no second date to fall back on.

Tickets for all three are sold through Kelly Strayhorn Theater, and each event page links to its own ticketing.

Before December, Two Warmups on the Same Blocks

The same two buildings have dates before the Nutcrackers arrive.

  1. Belle Voci Concert: Sounds of the Season, Saturday, Nov. 21, 2–4 p.m. East Liberty Presbyterian Church's November calendar lists this as an annual sensory-friendly holiday concert in the church's Social Hall.
  2. Suite Life: A Celebration of Billy Strayhorn & Gene Kelly, Saturday, Nov. 28. The theater honors its two namesakes. A VIP soundcheck reception and awards run 6 to 7 p.m. for $100 to $200, and the concert follows from 7:30 to 9 p.m. with tickets from $35 to $65. Details are on the Suite Life event page.

Suite Life amounts to an overture for the December run. It's a night about the two men on the marquee, two weeks before a ballet set to music one of them arranged.

Where to Eat, Matched to the Curtain

Show times fall on different days of the week, and so do kitchen hours. Here's which nearby spots line up with which nights, based on each restaurant's posted hours. Holiday weeks can shift schedules, so check before you go.

  • Margaux, 5947 Penn Ave. It's right next door to the theater. Margaux posts hours of 8 a.m. to 11 p.m. Tuesday through Friday and 9 a.m. to 11 p.m. Saturday, which covers the Saturday Jazz Nutcracker, the Wednesday fair and the Thursday ballet.
  • Duo's Taqueria, 5906 Penn Ave. It's in Pittsburgh Magazine's 2026 restaurant guide. Duo's lists dinner from 5 to 9 p.m. Tuesday through Thursday and 5 to 10 p.m. Friday and Saturday. For the 7 p.m. curtains, that means an early dinner on Dec. 12 or Dec. 17.
  • Hey Babe, 120 S. Whitfield St. According to East Liberty Development Inc., Hey Babe added a 50-seat reservable dining room this year, and the original lounge stays walk-in. The kitchen runs 4:30 to 10 p.m. Monday through Thursday and 4:30 to 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday. It's closed Sunday, so plan around it for the matinee.
  • Mola, 6018 Penn Ave. Mola posts hours every day of the week, including noon to 8:30 p.m. on Sunday, so it works both before and after the Dec. 13 matinee.
  • Palm Palm, 5996 Centre Ave. Palm Palm starts dinner at 3:30 p.m. daily and serves until 11 p.m. on Friday and Saturday. That suits a drink after the ELPC concert lets out at 9 p.m. on Dec. 11. It also serves weekend brunch.
  • Square Cafe, 134 S. Highland Ave. Square Cafe is open 7 a.m. to 3 p.m. daily, which makes it the matinee option. Brunch on South Highland, then the 2 p.m. Jazz Nutcracker.

The schedule turns into a simple plan. On Friday, it's the church sanctuary and a late table on Centre. On Saturday, it's an early dinner on Penn and Strayhorn's score at 7. On Sunday, it's brunch on Highland and the matinee. On Wednesday, it's the gift fair on a school night. On Thursday, it's the ballet in lights.

Kate is a fifth-generation Pittsburgher, and for The Kate White Team, a week like this on Penn Avenue is part of why the East End is home. If you're weighing a move in the new year and want to know what your house would bring in today's market, start with a free home valuation, and we'll talk it over with the neighborhood in mind.

Work With Kate

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today to find out how I can be of assistance to you!

Follow Us on Instagram